
Why Your Medicare Part D Costs Could Change Next Year — Even If You Don't Switch Plans
Every fall, a lot of people take the same approach to Medicare's Open Enrollment: if nothing's gone wrong, leave it alone. It's an understandable instinct — nobody enjoys wading through plan comparisons. But with Part D prescription drug coverage, "doing nothing" isn't actually neutral. Your plan can change significantly under you, even while your mailing address, your doctor, and your daily pills all stay exactly the same.
Your plan is allowed to change its formulary every year
A formulary is simply the list of drugs a plan covers, organized into tiers that determine your out-of-pocket cost. Insurance companies are permitted to update formularies annually — adding drugs, removing them, or moving a drug to a higher-cost tier. That update typically arrives with your Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) letter, which plans are required to send by September 30 each year.
The practical effect: the exact same plan name you had last year, covering the exact same medication, can cost meaningfully more in the new plan year if that medication moved from a lower tier to a higher one, or if the plan changed which pharmacies count as "preferred." None of that requires you to do anything wrong — it simply requires you to not have read the notice closely.
Most people don't actually check
This isn't a hypothetical risk. In one reader survey conducted by the Medicare information site medicareresources.org, only 35% of respondents said they review their Part D coverage options every year. Another 19% said they simply let their coverage renew without checking, and 10% said they review "from time to time," but not annually. Put differently: most people are not actively confirming their plan still fits before the window to change it closes.
That matters more in years when formularies shift than in years when they don't — and there's no way to know which kind of year it's been without actually looking.
What to actually check before December 7
- Read the ANOC letter that came with your plan materials. It specifically calls out what's changing for your plan next year — premium, deductible, and formulary or pharmacy network changes.
- Confirm each of your medications is still covered, and at what tier. A drug moving from Tier 2 to Tier 4 can mean a real jump in your copay or coinsurance, even with no change to your prescription.
- Check whether your regular pharmacy is still "preferred." Preferred-network pharmacies typically offer lower costs; a network change can quietly raise what you pay even at the same pharmacy counter you've always used.
- Use Medicare's Plan Finder at Medicare.gov to compare your current plan against alternatives using your actual medication list, not just the plan's overall star rating.
- Mark your calendar for December 7. That's the hard deadline for Open Enrollment changes to take effect January 1 — there's no extension for "I meant to look at this."
The takeaway
None of this requires predicting the future or becoming a Medicare expert overnight. It requires about twenty minutes with your ANOC letter and your medication list before the enrollment window closes. The people who get surprised by a cost increase in January are almost always the ones who assumed "same plan name" meant "same coverage."
Medicare decisions are one piece of a bigger retirement income picture — right alongside Social Security timing and how your savings are positioned to cover the rest. If you'd like a second set of eyes on how your healthcare costs fit into your overall plan, get a free Retirement Readiness Review and we'll help you look at the whole picture together.
Sources: Medicare.gov, "Open Enrollment"; medicareresources.org reader survey, "Majority of Survey Participants Don't Review Their Medicare Part D Coverage Options Annually." This article is educational only and not personalized financial, tax, or legal advice.
